Are the new criminal laws better or worse? | India’s Top Lawyers | Sibal, AM Singhvi, Mukul Rohatgi

38 thoughts on “Are the new criminal laws better or worse? | India’s Top Lawyers | Sibal, AM Singhvi, Mukul Rohatgi”

1. More discussion before implementation

2. Critical is very much needed
   As you pointed out there are some laws that ate much worse than that of previous

   This doesn't mean new system must be postponed
   It should be improvised

   Sibbal sir logic is like , throwing baby with the bath water

3. Why lawyers who are opposite spectrum in ideology are not seen in picture only left liberal leaning lawyers are voicing one sided view

4. Esmese doo ki dukandari bandh honewali hey.Wait & watch.These two have degraded judiciary by their acts.

5. Indian legal system is worst ever.

6. Law is not for common people and common lawyer of india,
   Law is only for for super rich lawyers and super criminal and terrorist

7. Plz made some changes in cheque bounce case. Everywhere accused didn't take summons 8 to 12 month but court continue send summons and avoid where is justice. I file complant in feb 2023 but accused didn't present yet where is justice.

8. Mechanical remand by magistrates will ruin the judicial process.

9. Co operation in this context is with the prosecution to investigation process and police and court.

10. During 2019 to 2022,,,,,,bails were sold out in the court anekal by Syed Baleegur Rahaman,,,,,,this discussion by these stalwarts is imaginary,,,,,,,,

11. These three senior lawyer appearing for only politician and big business house
    They are not for common citizen

12. Select committee examined
    Two houses passed
    President assent obtained
    Lawyers respect law
    Loopholes in law in the course of operations will be examined by SC
    Why this fuss
    Emanating fron primordial hatred for Modi Govt to please IND alliance

13. Supreme Court has deviated from their duties and are now involved in petty cases.
    Structural changes has to be done from Supreme Court cascading to high courts and lower courts.

14. And these are the "Top Liers"? 😂😂😂

15. Desko tumhari tarah chalana chahte ho kiyu ki sibbal jaise sub sating karke chalana chahte hai. Manu sigvi kapil sibbal judges bhi apooint karege or sc me manmani karke desme aantavad felyege.

16. Very informative discussion.

17. Political criminals manege withnes people ,real sufferers cannot got justice in India

18. All Indian laws used for first political stupids to enjoy luted money, power, escape from imprisonment with help judges litigation incriminal law

19. Best video ever❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤

20. good discussion. reinvention of criminal laws is required. i have personally suffered because of this faulty system.

21. Kapil now a job less advocate 😂😂😂😂

22. 🙏😍🙏

23. It is an irony that most of the Criminals are from our own Party!

24. What about the old criminals of the sitting mps

25. बडी अर्थपूर्ण चर्चा!

26. I can guarantee you that Sanghis and Rutta practioners can't be trusted philosophers as Thomas Stuart Mill, John Stuart Mill both father son duo influenced by Jeremy Bentham. I can't afford to conclude that new IPC and CRPC could match the reason, logic and commonsense of original codes. Lexically orginal discourse and gaze perspective of the Lex Corpus would same.
    It's not ditto to copy then paste a Neruda or Tagore literally putting trite in a different language and interchanging nouns, situation-scenario and sentences and become great as Neruda and Tagore.
    Letter to letter transliteration even earn the flair, class, taste with an ease – essentially reflecting the original sense, scope and function at par in face value.
    In the name of de-colonisation the argument, justification for changing the district administration is neither feasible nor acceptable. It's hilarious to see things literally replaced just for the sake of replacing – every thoughtful and genuinely thinking person must be in utter awe and wonder!

27. Two questions. Why Mr. Sibal and the congress government did nothing to reform the laws? Second, when governments don't care about rule of law and abuse them to target dissidents (including any judges who may rule agianst the govt), whats the recourse?

28. Wonderful lawyers…I fell why CJIs don't realize these common issues which they definitely know….every new CJI surprisingly becomes ineffective or biased…

29. Our entire Judicial system needs to be revamped sir.

30. Very nice topic of discussion

31. who is changing the IPC without consent of majority of indian people

32. Show me the Man I'll show you the law. Our judicial system in a nutshell😢.

33. Excellent video content is important 👍

34. ❤

35. Not Top but rich kanjoos lawyers😂

36. Police custody very disapointing thanks God in this election people mandate has checked the wheem of unruly legislature what they wanted to continued atleast 2045
    The mindset appers they would have frmed by ordinance a authority above Apex court headed by expart like Jay Saha type
    Now they can not do that's what INDIA advocates democracy is at stake seemed genuine

37. Currently many cases are pending for years.Obviously current laws and courts infrastructure is inadequate .
    The new laws must have been discussed before making law
    Let them be implemented and modified as the problems that arise

38. New criminal lnal law can it make pm or hm culprits in illegal electoral bond collection using ED CBI

Comments are closed.